From sundaes to gelato to soft serve to ice cream sandwiches, you can have delicious frozen treats at the ice cream shops in Brooklyn.
Brooklyn has a lot of great places if you want to have ice cream. Besides classic flavors, such as chocolate and vanilla, you can also get creative flavors at many of these places, such as red chili chocolate and pumpkin coconut. Also, there are places where you can get delicious vegan treats, such as dairy-free gelato and sorbet.
If you want to have a delicious frozen treat while exploring Brooklyn, I got you covered. These are the best places for ice cream in Brooklyn!
Best Ice Cream Shops in Brooklyn
OddFellows Ice Cream Co
Why you should visit OddFellows: There are many unique flavors, such as the “Peanut Butter S’Mores” and the “Vegan Matcha Latte”
OddFellows Ice Cream Co is a small-batch ice cream company that opened its first shop in 2013. Nowadays, there are many more locations, including three in Brooklyn.
At OddFellows Ice Cream Co., you can get all kinds of unique flavors. In total, the company has made more than 500 different types of flavors, which have included very creative ones as well as improved classics.
One of the best flavors to get is the “Peanut Butter S’Mores”, which is a flavor that is made with a peanut butter ice cream base, graham cracker crumbs, burnt marshmallows, and dark chocolate.
Another great flavor is the “Vegan Matcha Latte”, which is made with coconut and matcha.
Some other great flavors include “Strawberry Jam”, “Vanilla Bean”, and “Sprinkles”.
Address: 44 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Davey’s Ice Cream
Must-try: The “Strong Coffee” flavor
Davey’s Ice Cream is a place where you can get delicious ice cream that is homemade in Brooklyn. This place was founded in 2013 and has four locations throughout New York City. In Brooklyn, you can find Davey’s at 74 Meserole Avenue in Greenpoint. Going to this location is also one of the best things to do in Greenpoint.
The treats that you can get here are made with all-natural milk and cream from local creameries, and seasonal ingredients. The store makes its own bases in-house.
There are many great flavors to choose from, including classic ones, such as the “Fresh Strawberry” and “Chocolate Chocolate”, as well as more unique ones, such as the “Strong Coffee”, which is a coffee ice cream that is made with Birch Coffee coffee beans.
This place also sells a variety of specialty ice cream cakes.
Address: 74 Meserole Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Malai
Why you need to visit Malai: There’s ice cream that’s made with aromatic spices and South Asian ingredients
Malai is an ice cream shop in Brooklyn that you can go to every day of the week and that you can find at 268 Smith Street.
At this place, you can get delicious treats that are made with South Asian ingredients and aromatic spices, and the ice cream at Malai is made without eggs and churned with little air, which ensures a creamy texture. In addition to that, Malai uses dairy from local New York farms.
You can get many unique flavors at Malai that you won’t find at other ice cream stores.
One of the best flavors is the “Golden Tumeric”, which is made with ginger and a spice blend.
Another great flavor is “Red Chili Chocolate”, which is a chocolate ice cream with chili.
Besides year-round flavors, there are also seasonal flavors. One of the best seasonal flavors is the “Fig on Fig”, which is available in summer, and which is made with toasted fig leaves and a dried fig jam.
There are also vegan flavors that are made with coconut milk and vegan white chocolate. The “Chocolate Coconut Burfi” is a great one to try. This is a dairy-free chocolate sorbet with a cardamom coconut fudge.
Address: 268 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Island Pops
Must-try: The unique popsicles of Island Pops
Island Pops is a place where you can get delicious ice cream made with natural, tropical ingredients from the Caribbean. You can find this place at 680 Nostrand Avenue.
The ice cream store makes lots of different flavors, some of which are available all year round, and that you can get on a cone, in a cup, or on a stick.
One of the best year-round flavors is the “Grapenut” flavor, and another great flavor is the “Cherry Vanilla” flavor.
You can also get sorbet, vegan treats, and popsicles at Island Pops. One of the best popsicle flavors is the “Lemon Lime Basil”.
There is also a seasonal menu, with flavors that are available during the summer, fall, or winter.
For example, during the summer, you can get delicious “Cherry Blossom” ice cream, and a great flavor during the fall is the “Pumpkin Coconut” flavor.
Address: 680 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11216
Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory
Why you should go here: You can get delicious classic flavors at this place, as well as some unique ones
The Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory is located in Brooklyn Heights, near the Brooklyn Bridge. You can find it at 14 Old Fulton Street but was originally located across the street, in the Fulton Ferry Fireboat House. The store was established in 2001.
You can choose from a variety of classic flavors that are all very delicious.
For example, you can get the “Chocolate” flavor, which is made with a housemade chocolate blend that is made with naturally-processed cocoa powder and turbinado sugar.
The “Coffee” flavor is a great flavor as well. This one is made with decaffeinated coffee and almost no water. The concentrated decaffeinated coffee is blended with the cream right before being frozen.
Another classic flavor that I recommend getting is the “Butter Pecan” flavor. This flavor is made with whole pecans that are crushed by hand.
Having ice cream here is also one of the best things to do in Brooklyn Heights.
Address: 14 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Taiyaki NYC
Known for: Unique soft serve that’s served in a fish-shaped ice cream cone
Taiyaki NYC is an ice cream store with various locations throughout New York City. One of these locations is in Brooklyn’s Williamsburg, at 294 Bedford Avenue. This location opened in 2018.
You can get fresh and unique soft serve that is served in fish-shaped cones at this place, and the ice cream is produced in small batches.
You can get both classic and creative flavors, and you can choose one of the signature Taiyakis or you can build your own by choosing the cup or cone, the flavor or combo flavor, the syrup, and the toppings that you want.
One of the best signature options is the “Straight Out of Japan”, which is a fish-shaped cone with matcha and hojicha ice cream, a red bean taiyaki cone, and rainbow mochi.
Another great signature is “The Choco-Lit”. This one comes with chocolate ice cream, a custard taiyaki cone, chocolate powder and a chocolate drizzle, and a wafer stick.
Address: 294 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249
Ice Cream House
Highlights: There are unique ice cream cakes in all kinds of flavors
Ice Cream House has three locations in Brooklyn. One of these stores is located in Williamsburg at 873 Bedford Avenue.
You can get all kinds of ice cream here, including soft serve, gelato, sundaes, ice cakes, and other options.
There are many flavors to choose from. Some of the best flavors that you can get are the “Swiss Chocolate”, “Strawberry Banana”, and “Cotton Candy” flavors.
The ice cream cakes at this place come in all kinds of flavors, such as coffee, cookies & cream, and strawberry.
Address: 873 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Must-try: The ice cream bars, such as the “Vanilla Caramel Swirl”
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream has many locations and was founded in 2008. It started with a yellow ice cream truck. The treats that you can get at Van Leeuwen are made with high-quality ingredients.
You can get all kinds of flavors at this place, including many vegan ones.
Two of the best flavors to get are the “Chocolate Caramel Cheesecake” and the “Malted Cookie Dough Shake”. The latter is made with chewy malted ice cream, cookie dough, and dark chocolate chips.
You can also get ice cream bars, such as the “Vanilla Caramel Swirl”, which is made with vanilla ice cream, and a swirl of caramel that is wrapped in milk chocolate.
If you want to have vegan treats, there are many delicious options. One of the best flavors is the “Vegan Strawberry Shortcake”, which is made with vanilla, strawberry jam, and pieces of shortcake.
In addition to that, you can also get ice cream sandwiches at Van Leeuwen. For example, you can get the vegan double chocolate vanilla, which is made with vegan vanilla ice cream that is sandwiched between two double chocolate chip cookies.
Address: 1 Water St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
Ample Hills Creamery
We recommend: The “Morning in Paris” flavor
Ample Hills Creamery is one of the best ice cream shops in Brooklyn if you want to try creative flavors. The company was established in 2010 and focuses on creative flavors. It has three locations in Brooklyn.
One of the best flavors to get is the “Morning in Paris”, which is a butter croissant-infused ice cream with swirls of raspberry jam.
Another great flavor to get is the “Peppermint Pattie”, which is a cool peppermint ice cream with housemade dark chocolate, chocolate flakes, and peppermint patties.
The “PB Wins the Cup” is a great flavor to try as well. This one is made with vanilla ice cream, housemade peanut butter cups, and peanut butter-infused chocolate flakes.
Keep in mind that the availability of the flavors varies, depending on which location you go to.
Visiting Ample Hills Creamery is also one of the best things to do in Prospect Heights.
Address: 623 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
More Brooklyn Articles
Things to do with kids in Brooklyn
Rainy day activities in Brooklyn
Ice Cream in Brooklyn Tips
When you are going to have ice cream in Brooklyn, I recommend using the map that I included in this article to see if there’s a place near one of these places that you want to visit.
For example, you can find one of the locations of Van Leeuwen close to Brooklyn Bridge Park, and going there is one of the best things to do in Brooklyn.
Brooklyn Ice Cream Shops Map
As you see, there are a lot of great places you can go to for a delicious frozen treat. Thanks for reading my guide to the best ice cream shops in Brooklyn!